
I have come to the conclusion that it is simply a crime that Lula Magazine is not available (or at least not available without a very hefty price tag) where I live, and that it is truly a mini-tragedy that I am repeatedly deprived of such great art and fashion. Thank the heavens for people with Lula mags on hand and a scanner to boot. Because what can I say? Lula is simply inspiration packed!

And inspiration itself happens to be my topic for this entry. I guess I'm particularly interested in discussing the subject of inspiration, because yesterday I came across someone who had a blog entry that eerily mirrored a previous entry of mine. The images where yes, different, but of the same type and topic, and the text, though the wording wasn't an exact copy, essentially repeated what I said. Even the entry's layout was precisely done in the same Polaroid picture-couple lines of narrative-Polaroid picture-couple lines of narrative ... format.

I know for a fact that this person reads my blog (they list my blog in their blog roll), though I will refrain from calling them out by name. After all, I don't mean to be cruel or come off as bitter... more so, I suppose I am a bit confused and conflicted on how to react.

I know it's often said that when someone copies you, it's really just a form of flattery. And those people will often defend themselves and their case by shrugging, and saying they were simply inspired by you. But where does one draw the line between inspired, and "copycat", to use a children's term. And are there situations in which one's copying nears such likeness to the original that it could almost be labeled as plagiarism?

I must confess, that when someone asks permission to recreate something I've done, or when given credit for inspiration that results in someone creating something undeniably like something of mine... I feel much better than when they copy and act naively like they have no idea where the inspiration came from.

I think it's all about how you process the inspiration you receive. For me personally, I am frequently and easily inspired, however I exude much effort to ensure prevention of direct copying. I seek to put a distinct spin on whatever I am inspired by. The lovely part is when your inspiration is a "what" not a "who", because in my opinion, everyone has free reign of object-inspiration. You don't need to fret that nature, or other non man-made/human sources of inspiration, will sue you for copyright and creative infringement.

There is though, subconscious inspiration, which is a tricky little thing to tango with, because you might be unaware, whatsoever, that you even have a partner in your creation. So to say, occasions in which you are inspired and aren't even consciously aware that you have been. Usually subconscious inspiration is unknowingly stored away in your mind, and later, may slip out in something you do. You realize you've been inspired, but can't recall the source of inspiration.

Really though, in regards to this "copying" situation, I hope I'm not coming off as a snob about it. Because I actually am delighted to to hear people say I or something I've shared has inspired them. I suppose I just expect them to cultivate that inspiration in a fresh way, thus producing a whole new crop of inspiration. I believe one has a duty to take care of how they use their inspiration, so as to avoid ripping off others, and even, in some cases, law suits. When used correctly though, inspiration can be like a gift that keeps on giving.
Photo Credits: Selected images from "Love Letter", issue #5 of Lula Magazine, scans by kissmesweet @ www.thefashionspot.com
25 comments:
yes the pictures are great!!thanks for sharing
I love it when I find inspiration in something I would never have realised could inspire me - like an object I see in the street or even something random like a colour!
hi!!!
ive noticed your blog a few days a go and u have a really good taste in photos!
anyways if u want i have a flickr where i always add my fave photography
http://flickr.com/photos/reactor_carousel/
(u can only see the last 200 entries, soon ill get the pro account, cant be bothered for now, just dont want to save pics on pc as im using my dads now and he gets sooo annoyed)
anyways the last 100 entries are from lula.
if u miss any pictures ask me i might have them saved somewhere on my other pc. like the last issue 7 i have each photo...
lots of love!
daria
ps
really enjoy your blog *_*
hi love.
your words. they truly are blissful... you are far too kind. again- a genuine, heart-filled thank you. you are such a shining star & i feel blessed to have met you on here!
i totally understand what you are saying. My oh my. YOU put SO much of yourself into these posts: passion...thought...time...and to see it almost replicated without any "props" TO that inner self is hurtful.
i agree with you fully.
SO wish i had access to lula right now! so dreamy............
xx.
Maybe because you have such a unique style you have now invented a new way of posting...you have a really interesting blog Ilove reading what you write :)
Very blond Audrey Hepburn, especially the first two. I love it!
I wish the lighting would get better, unfortunately today is rainy yet again.. :/ it's OK I am in the middle of moving anyway, after I get settled into the new place, maybe I can make a little "photo shoot" :)
xo/ fashion chalet
I can't get Lula easily either! It is so sad, because it is truly inspirational.
What amazing photos.
and don't worry, you will always be the most original and amazing!
Love your words.
Agreed! And the issue of online infringement is a tricky one. For example I love Bazaar but all their images are flash so you can't copy them, which is annoying.
These pics are gorgeous, S-C!
xoxox,
CC
This reminds me of something that occurred few months ago (on my website): I was doing some research for an article (I usually use several distinct source for a subject for a global approach) and came across a tfs entry with a post reminding me so much of my own writing that I thought my mind was playing games on me. I went on my site, checked it out, compared the dates and my article, identical with the one posted in that article (as quoted from a completely other website than mine) was written after my article. I went out on a wild mad hunt and made it public (on my website). You wouldn't believe it, but the owner of the stealer-site showed up shamelessly, without naming who she/he was (but I have my own ways to find out who she/he really was, by tracking the comment referring link) and said that many writers use the same sources, hence the similarities from the two articles. It was scandalous! She/he changed the articles stolen from me (there were several, I checked on their website), slightly modifying the phrases, and that was it. Never returned to steal again.
Unfortunately you can't chase everybody down when this happens. One because you're not always aware of that and two because you don't always have irrefutable proof to cast the stone.
Don't waste time on this kind of things, people who read you know your style ;) (if everyone would really credit their sources, this wouldn't happen)
Hey, I know what you mean. Black can go both ways. I just love the sleekness is invokes. I may do an "all black" look sometime. Remind me, if I need reminding (after the move!) ;) We are moving only an hour away. But still, it's a pain. Re-organizing everything, getting settled, used to the place, etc. etc. You know what it's like... On the plus side, I get a walk in that is a lot bigger plus an extra small closet, that I will now deem for my shoes. :)
xo/ fashion chalet
I bought Lula magazine a few weeks ago (for $27!!!) and I still haven't read it. I'm saving it for when I have the time to really savour the images.
I think when people blatantly copy something which you see as being a unique aspect of yourself, it does grate a little. It almost feels like they're taking your identity because we often feel that creative endeavours outwardly show who we are as individuals.
I have noticed a few blogs incorporate elements that I use, particular phrases or topics and I think it's a subconscious thing so I'm not worried about it all - sometimes you can't help it! But making a conscious effort to replicate someone else's creativity is a bit much.
PS. Thank you so much for your lovely comments - my smile is always a mile wide when I read them :D
i love your photos.
nice blog, fellow new yorker!
what college are you attending? out of curiosity :)
I love that girl!
she looks so fairy-ish!!
yummo.
..
that was dirty.
Beautiful pictures. I love this kind of retro aesthetics.
Hi sweetheart!
Another amazing post... <3
I hope you're not letting those people who shamelessly copy you, make you feel sad or anything.
As you said yourself, it is a way of flattering of course, but i can understand how you feel about it.
I've never noticed someone copying my posts, but as i am thinking right now: i also copy, but only lots of pictures made or found by other people. That os course is also a way of copying.
However, inspiration is something so important for me (and for a lot of others of course) so i am mostly happy with all these thousands of blogs with a lot of different and unique styles. Some people can't do it on their own and can only create a blog by copying others. It's just a little sad they don't have the creativity to do what you're doing... :)
I think they have to learn that they can enjoy someone else's creativity and originality, without using it themselves to get compliments for themselves, when it's really not theirs.
I hope for them they will learn that. It's not all about being noticed and appreciated by others, it's more about enjoying little things in life and enjoying other people's creativity (that they want to share with you all!).
Not everyone's that creative or can come up with original stuff, but that's not a bad thing. What would the world look like if everybody was as creative as some people? ;)
I hope you know what i mean, a little...
<3
Mila.
I'm just reading through the comments here and realised how many people actually read what you've written. quite amusing actually what kind of reaction you get. then again what people write here as comment is completely their discretion I suppose.
When you post something online you’re implicitly taking a risk. Anyone and everyone can copy and there’s very little you and I can do really as you well know. Blog world fortunately is self-managed and corrected. You have all the right to feel ‘crap’ about it. You could feel hard done by even. Someone taking credit for the work you put into… that happens a lot.
I once did a post on someone (in Russia) lifting a photo directly off someone’s blog and didn’t credit. A whole lot of people went crazy. The culprit’s attitude was utterly oblivious. You can imagine how that photographer would have felt.
Just be yourself. Never stop being creative. Those who copy all the time will soon run out of steam as they never had any creative energy to start with.
I did create my second blog which is very much like {this is glamorous} blog. Someone could argue that I copied that blog. It’s using the same Blogger template ( as with hundreds out there), similar format (mainly images), similar kind of images (magazine copies) but I never copy their stuff. I collect my own material and that’s that. If I happen to post the same thing then it’s a complete coincidence. I think there’s a very fine line. My example here maybe is not that relevant. Anyway.. my blathering over. Songy out.
stunning pics
Love the photos! But I've never heard of Lula magazine - which country is it from? Agree with fashion chalet, the pics are really blonde Audrey Hepburn. Love it. Adore all the clothes.
Okay...that blogger who basically copied your entry must have been really mean! I don't think that's fair. Okay, you shouldn't expose this person in public, maybe, but I'd just leave him/her a comment or send him/her an e-mail saying that you will not have this, and that next time, he/she should ask for permission. Nice, but sincere ^^ the way you described it, this person is a copy cat. It sounds like he/she just copied and pasted your post into the "create post" box and just re-phrased your sentences in their own words and used slightly different pictures. If he/she just repeated what you said, basically, and didn't involve his/her own opinion at all, it's not inspiration anymore, it's copying.
The subconscious inspiration reminds me of class tests: You are asked to summarize a text, and subconsciously you use many phrases which are direct quotations from the text, but you're convinced that they came from your own mind.
LOVELY lovely lovely
thanks so much for this post
xoxo
You have excellent taste. I love the pictures.
i have added you to my blog links.
x
S
i love these pictures!
i can't get Lula either.
it's a bit depressing really.
Keep up the fantastic posts!
Oh beleive me, you don't want the weather, it's so dull it brings you down haha. Trade anyday?
Although I do adore being able to dress up in coats and knitwear, the best season I think!
Adore the images in this post!
BSB
these are so great- peaceful, serene and inspirational. been loving your choice of photos :) thanks for sharing
beautiful pictures!
Oh I hate subways! In London, it just feels so musky underground, if you understand me when I say that?
I live i England, currently in the South, I travel around, London and Brighton alot.
I am planning on visitng NYC next year, it seems like such a beautifully busy place, I'd love to just sit with a hot chocolate and watch the world go by!
Where is good to go there? Any tips?
xox
BSB
Post a Comment